Top-order captainsWhy they dominate
Top-order batters face more balls than middle-order batters. More balls = more opportunities for runs, boundaries, milestones, and strike-rate bonuses. Combined with the captaincy multiplier, top-order captains have the highest ceiling of any captaincy option.
Allrounder captainsThe second tier
Allrounders as captains are the second most successful pattern. They combine batting points with bowling points, and their dual-role status gives them a high floor. The downside is that allrounders are more expensive in the salary cap, which constrains the rest of the lineup.
Bowler captainsHigh risk, high reward
Bowler captains are the rarest successful pattern - only 6-11% of grand-prize winners across the last five seasons. Bowler captains have a higher ceiling when they take a 4- or 5-wicket haul, but their floor is lower because they cannot accumulate batting points.
Wicketkeeper captainsThe dark horse
Wicketkeeper captains have grown as a share of grand-prize winners, from 4% in 2021 to 9% in 2025. The pattern is driven by wicketkeeper-batters who bat in the top four - they accumulate batting, captaincy, wicketkeeping and fielding points.